Penance's Comments

This pet makes no sense. 

The covenant lock isn't ideal, but I can deal with it.  But not to be able to battle or even level my pet without the use of stones?!  Ridiculous.  Why does he even have skills if he can't battle?  It makes no sense.

Beautiful, unique model that I'm happy to have as my companion on my (luckily) main character, but the rest of it takes almost all of the enjoyment out of owning Jiggles.

Caught mine within 5 minutes of starting at the Shado-Pan Monastary, fishing in Tiger Gourami pools, standing on the ice floes.  

I'd tried one evening before for maybe 10 minutes, before going to bed, so total time invested was maybe 15 minutes, although it was apparently a lucky catch,

My first catch and it caught me off guard since it happened so quickly.

My fishing skill is 889 buffed (fishing rod, hat, special fishing line) but I don't have the Pandaren Fishing Charm on this (my main) character).

Got mine tonight, fishing in the pool near Niuzao Temple, open water.  I tried fishing in the few redbelly mandarin pools that popped up, too, but no luck there.  Also no luck in the spinefish pools.

I tend to believe the people who say that these don't drop out of spinefish schools, only from the open water near the Temple or there and redbelly mandarin pools.

My fishing skill is 889 buffed (fishing rod, hat, special fishing line) but I don't have the Pandaren Fishing Charm on this (my main) character).

When this drops, it drops on its own, not sealed in a crate.  It's a white text item that says Tiny Blue Carp and then turns blue text when used.

Got mine today from a jewel danio pool on Timeless Isle next to the Celestial Court about 10 minutes after I got the Tiny Red Carp (and the last color I needed).  Beware the ally and horde PvP going on in the area.

My fishing skill is 889 buffed (fishing rod, hat, special fishing line) but I don't have the Pandaren Fishing Charm on this character.