ahh, I see that one, that works now

Came here for this exact reason and to also note that there is no "got it" option on this pet either so I still can't add it to my list.

I've been curious if this was a bug on the site or if I have something done wrong, but all the pets in my "wanted" list have a grey tint over them, making it a bit hard to see them, even the check on the tab for "wanted" is greyed out, is there some way to change this?