Cross Posting this here from another thread I only tracked HP as that seemed to be the number that was indicative of rarity. (times # indicates how many I caught before moving on to the next pet) Blighted Squirrels in Silverpine: Level 5: 520 HP: rare 467 HP (times 2): uncommon 415 HP: common 378 HP...

Apparently, the amount of HP a pet has compared to its level is a good clue. There certainly seems to be some truth to this. After reading this thread, I decided I'd try it out. Blighted Squirrels in Silverpine: Edit: added more numbers level 5 with 520 HP: rare level 5 with 467 HP (times 2): uncom...