Same problem here. It shows I have zero pets

I can't seem to get the crawling claw or the fox. A friend didn't even know about the fox till we were out doing the dailies there and he asked me why I was killing the foxes so he kills the next few and he gets it.

I think my first pets were the cats from Elwyn Forest. Then my boyfriend bought me the white kitten from the AH. That's when I became pet obsessed.

For me it's the fox. I took a friend over to there for his first time and he asked why I was killing those foxes. I told him and on his fourth kill he got it.