I have been having the same problem for a while now. The thing that just caught my attention is that you are on Bladefist(US) and I am on the linked realm Kul Tiras. Maybe this is realm specific? I have bypassed the problem by switching to a toon on another server, updating my record, and then switc...

On 7 toons .... got one on my 56th attempt (last toon yesterday).

None from presents under the tree today so not sure anyone can count on those.

I did get a 2nd one from todays dailies though

I have a Darkmoon Eye available and I'd like to trade for a Vengeful Porcupette. I might be able to throw in another pet (or stones) though I don't have a lot spare.

If interested in talking about it let me know here or in game .

*Edit
Trade made. Thanks Dasaq!