I tried all the solutions advised but unfortunately the only chars I haven't logged into yet are the low level ones that this site doesn't recognize.

How long until they fix this? I've been adding all the new pets and want to show them.

So, weirdly I logged out and then changed my character to another character on the same realm and it was back to the right amount. But then I tried to change it to another alt and it didn't work. Only thing I can think of is the second character I tried had special characters in her wow name...same...

Question: If there are only 574 possible pets, how come some of the high leaders have more than that?
Nevermind I figured it out.