Argent Gruntling / Squire

[Swaps]

I got the Gruntling on my character, but the Squire is still showing missing on my profile here. Since I can't add another character, how are people getting credit for both here?

[Quintessence]

The Argent Gruntling and Argent Squire are two separate pets, so you'll need to collect the Argent Squire on an alliance character.

[Swaps]

How do I add 2 characters to my profile here? Or will it pull automatically from one toon?

[Quintessence]

There's no need to create a second account on WarcraftPets or add a second character. All pets are account-wide now, so any pets you collect on an alliance character will automatically be added to your overall collection. Importing your collection from the armory will include any and all pets that you've collected (that are on the armory), regardless of your faction.